I really really really want 1x rates , but it's not going to be easy to level at all , 4 xp for 1 hit... Free to play... No p2p items to train easier , all items from scratch... Like cmon , i was like 10 when i played F2p back in like 2006 , i doubt i will have enough time now that i'm grown up to level all the way up to good stats enough to pk :/ , i prefer more like 2-5x rates , i know many will say it's too high , but face it guys , we all were pretty much lil kids when we played old skool rs , we had all the time in the world , but not anymore. 
Good rates: Between 2-5x.
Agreed.
How about if have a trial period of 2 weeks at 4x exp rate, and if it's too fast, we go lower?